
Heat Pump Pool Heater: How It Works, 12 Models Compared and Cost to Run vs Gas
A heat pump pool heater moves outdoor heat into your water at 4 to 7 times the energy it uses, but at 50 F air it delivers only 61% to 66% of its rated output.
- ✓12 models, three AHRI pointsHayward, Pentair, Jandy, AquaCal, Raypak and Fibropool sheets side by side, with amps, breaker and refrigerant.
- ✓Monthly cost vs gas, 5 citiesDOE city seasons repriced at 2025 EIA prices: Phoenix, Miami, Dallas, Atlanta and Chicago.
- ✓When gas still winsCold starts, spas and cheap-gas states, with the thresholds from maker sheets and EIA data.
Key takeaways
- A heat pump pool heater moves heat from outdoor air into the water; at AHRI 1160’s 80 F rating the 11 rated models compared here deliver 5.7 to 7.1 Btu of heat per Btu of electricity (AHRI test points on the Jandy JE sheet).
- At 50 F air the same models keep only 61% to 66% of their 80 F output and their COP falls to 4.0 to 4.2; the Pentair UltraTemp 140 drops from 145,000 to 90,000 Btu/h (Pentair 2025-2026 catalog).
- At July 2026 US average prices a heat pump at COP 5.0 put a million Btu into a pool for $10.73, against $31.14 for an 82% gas heater (EIA; PC&S cost to heat a pool study).
- Uncovered, a heat pump cost $277 a month in Atlanta against $772 for gas, but $430 vs $549 in Chicago, where 2025 gas was $11.25 per Mcf (DOE city tables repriced with EIA).
- Gas still wins on speed: a covered 20,000-gallon pool gains 20 F in about 10 hours with a 400,000 Btu/h gas heater and 25 hours with a 140,000 Btu/h heat pump (Pentair formula, PC&S loss model).
- Most units need a 208 to 230 V circuit with a 38 to 46 A minimum circuit ampacity, and every rated model here uses R-410A refrigerant (Raypak submittal, Aug 2026).
How does a heat pump pool heater work?
A heat pump pool heater works like an air conditioner run in reverse: a fan pulls outdoor air across a refrigerant coil, a compressor concentrates that heat, and a titanium heat exchanger hands it to the pool water. It burns nothing. The Hayward HeatPro HP21404T, for example, delivers 140,000 Btu/h from 7.2 kW of electricity at 80 F air.
- Fan and evaporator coilA top fan draws outdoor air over the evaporator coil. R-410A refrigerant inside the coil is colder than the air, so it absorbs heat and boils into a low-pressure gas.
- CompressorA scroll compressor squeezes the gas, which raises its temperature well above the 80 F pool water. This is the step that uses most of the 4.3 to 7.2 kW input on the sheets compared here.
- Titanium heat exchanger (condenser)Pool water from the filter flows through the heat exchanger at 30 to 75 gpm on Hayward HeatPro models; the hot refrigerant condenses and releases its heat into the water.
- Expansion valveThe liquid refrigerant passes an expansion valve (Pentair UltraTemp uses a thermostatic expansion valve), drops in pressure and temperature, and returns to the coil to start again.
- Defrost and controlsBelow about 50 F air the coil can frost; low-ambient models such as the Hayward HP31404T reverse the cycle to defrost and keep heating to 40 F air.

The coefficient of performance (COP) is heat delivered divided by electricity used, both in Btu. For the HP21404T at 80 F air that is 140,000 / (7.2 x 3,412) = 5.70, which matches the 5.7 printed on Hayward sell sheet LITHTPRO23; 3,412 Btu per kWh is the EIA conversion. A COP of 5.7 means about 82% of the heat comes free from the air and 18% from the meter.
DOE says COPs usually run from 3.0 to 7.0 and that heat pumps work efficiently while outdoor air stays above the 45 F to 50 F range (DOE Energy Saver, archived Jan 1, 2026). Heat pumps were about 25.8% of US pool heater units shipped against about 72% gas-fired, per DOE’s 2023 rulemaking data summarized in our gas pool heater rules registry.
What do the AHRI 1160 ratings on a pool heat pump mean?
AHRI Standard 1160 rates pool heat pumps at three points, all with 80 F water: 80 F air at 80% humidity, 80 F air at 63% humidity, and 50 F air at 63% humidity. The first is the headline number; the third predicts spring and fall output. On the 11 rated models compared here, output at the 50 F point is 61% to 66% of the headline.
| AHRI 1160 rating point | Air (dry bulb) | Relative humidity | Pool water | What it tells you | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| High temperature rating | 80 F | 80% | 80 F | Headline Btu and COP on most spec sheets; humid summer air | Jandy H0408600 footnote; Hayward LITHTPRO23 |
| Standard rating (federal test point) | 80 F | 63% | 80 F | The DOE federal test condition; drier summer air | DOE Energy Saver (archived); Jandy H0408600 |
| Low temperature rating | 50 F | 63% | 80 F | Spring and fall output; COP 4.0 to 4.2 on the 11 rated models | Jandy H0408600; Raypak 100-10009566 |
| California Title 20 floor | Average of standard and low ratings | n/a | n/a | Average COP must be at least 3.5 for units made since Mar 1, 2003 | 20 CCR 1605.3(g)(3) |
Source: Jandy JE manual H0408600; DOE Energy Saver; 20 CCR 1605.3(g)(3). Accessed Nov 3, 2026. Download CSV
COP falls in cool air for two reasons that show up on every sheet. Cooler, drier air holds less heat for the coil to collect, and the compressor must lift the refrigerant across a wider gap to reach 80 F water, so each kWh moves less heat. The Raypak Crosswind V 8550 shows both: 138,000 Btu/h at COP 6.0 at 80 F and 80% humidity, 87,000 Btu/h at COP 4.2 at 50 F (Raypak submittal 100-10009566).
Humidity matters too, because moisture condensing on the coil gives up extra heat. Dropping from 80% to 63% humidity at the same 80 F air trims 5,000 to 10,000 Btu/h on the rated models, for example 140,000 to 130,000 on the Hayward HP21404T and 132,000 to 127,000 on the Jandy JE3000T. Desert buyers in Phoenix or Las Vegas should read the 63% column, not the 80% one.
Heat pump pool heater specs: 12 models compared
Across 12 current models from six makers, AHRI-rated output at 80 F air runs from 85,000 to 145,000 Btu/h, COP from 5.7 to 7.1, and minimum circuit ampacity from 38 to 46 A. The 2026 shelf prices we captured for 120,000 to 145,000 Btu/h units ran $4,800 to $6,999. Fibropool, the first organic result for this keyword, publishes no AHRI 1160 points for its FH255.
| Model | 80 F air, 80% RH, 80 F water (Btu/h / COP) | 80 F air, 63% RH (Btu/h / COP) | 50 F air, 63% RH (Btu/h / COP) | Output kept at 50 F air | Electrical input (kW, 80 F) | Minimum circuit ampacity (A) | Breaker or fuse (A) | Refrigerant | Lowest heating air temperature | Price (retailer, date) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hayward HeatPro HP21004T | 90,000 / 5.7 | 85,000 / 5.5 | 59,000 / 4.0 | 66% | 4.9 | 38 | 40 min / 60 max | R-410A | 50 F | No 2026 listing captured | Hayward HeatPro sell sheet LITHTPRO23 |
| Hayward HeatPro HP21404T | 140,000 / 5.7 | 130,000 / 5.5 | 85,000 / 4.0 | 61% | 7.2 | 42 | 50 min / 60 max | R-410A | 50 F | $6,999, Walmart.com, Oct 14, 2026 | Hayward HeatPro sell sheet LITHTPRO23 |
| Hayward HeatPro HP31404T (low ambient, heat/cool) | 140,000 / 5.7 | 130,000 / 5.5 | 85,000 / 4.0 | 61% | 7.2 | 42 | 50 min / 60 max | R-410A | 40 F | No 2026 listing captured | Hayward HeatPro sell sheet LITHTPRO23 |
| Pentair UltraTemp 110 | 110,000 / 6.1 | 101,000 / 5.8 | 70,000 / 4.0 | 64% | Not listed | 42 | 50 rec / 70 max | R-410A | Not stated | No 2026 listing captured | Pentair 2025-2026 catalog, heaters section; UltraTemp manual |
| Pentair UltraTemp 140 | 145,000 / 5.8 | 135,000 / 5.6 | 90,000 / 4.0 | 62% | Not listed | 43 | 50 rec / 70 max | R-410A | Not stated | $5,499, SwimmingPoolSupplyUSA, Nov 3, 2026 | Pentair 2025-2026 catalog, heaters section; UltraTemp manual |
| Pentair UltraTemp ETi 220K hybrid (heat pump side) | 108,000 / 5.8 | 100,000 / 5.6 | 70,000 / 4.0 | 65% | Not listed | Not listed | 50 | Not stated | Gas side takes over | No 2026 listing captured | Pentair 2025-2026 catalog, heaters section; UltraTemp manual |
| Jandy JE3000T | 132,000 / 6.1 | 127,000 / 6.0 | 86,000 / 4.2 | 65% | 6.34 | 41.81 | 60 max | R-410A, 118 oz | Not stated | $5,699.95, Sunplay, Nov 3, 2026 | Jandy JE manual H0408600 Rev F |
| AquaCal HeatWave SuperQuiet SQ145 | 121,000 / 7.1 | 115,000 / 6.8 | 75,000 / 4.2 | 62% | 5.1 | 42.1 | 60 max fuse | R-410A | Not stated | $5,435, EZ Pools, Nov 3, 2026 | AquaCal HeatWave SuperQuiet brochure AC-2450 V8 (May 2024) |
| AquaCal HeatWave SuperQuiet SQ225 | 143,000 / 6.5 | 134,000 / 6.1 | 90,000 / 4.0 | 63% | 6.4 | 42.1 | 60 max fuse | R-410A | Not stated | $6,262, EZ Pools, Nov 3, 2026 | AquaCal HeatWave SuperQuiet brochure AC-2450 V8 (May 2024) |
| Raypak Crosswind V TWPH-4550EHT08 | 85,000 / 5.8 | 80,000 / 5.5 | 56,000 / 4.0 | 66% | 4.3 | 38 | 50 rec | R-410A | Not stated | No 2026 listing captured | Raypak submittal 100-10009566 Rev 01 (eff. Aug 20, 2026) |
| Raypak Crosswind V TWPH-8550EHT08 | 138,000 / 6.0 | 130,000 / 5.8 | 87,000 / 4.2 | 63% | 6.6 | 46 | 60 rec | R-410A | Not stated | $4,800, Leslie's (Wayback), Jun 30, 2026 | Raypak submittal 100-10009566 Rev 01 (eff. Aug 20, 2026) |
| Fibropool FH255 | 55,000 (maker rating at 82 F water, 82% humidity; not an AHRI 1160 point) | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | 12 gauge, 240 V circuit (maker) | Not stated on FH255 page | Not stated | $1,799.99, fibropool.com, Nov 3, 2026 | Fibropool FH255 product page |
Source: Hayward LITHTPRO23; Pentair 2025-2026 catalog and UltraTemp manual; Jandy H0408600 Rev F; AquaCal AC-2450 V8; Raypak 100-10009566; Fibropool FH255. Prices: Walmart.com, Leslie’s via Wayback, SwimmingPoolSupplyUSA, EZ Pools, Sunplay, fibropool.com, captured Jun 30 to Nov 3, 2026. Download CSV
Fibropool FH255 is left out: it publishes no AHRI 1160 rating points.
Source: Hayward LITHTPRO23; Pentair 2025-2026 catalog; Jandy H0408600; AquaCal AC-2450 V8; Raypak 100-10009566. Download chart data (CSV)
Two numbers on the table decide most purchases. The 50 F column says how much heat you get in April or October: the Pentair UltraTemp 140 and AquaCal SQ225 lead at 90,000 Btu/h, the Raypak 8550 follows at 87,000 and the Jandy JE3000T at 86,000. The breaker column says what your electrician must run: Pentair allows up to a 70 A breaker, Hayward and Jandy 60 A.

Prices move faster than specs. Leslie’s listed the Hayward HP21404T at $5,499 in April 2024 and Walmart.com at $6,999 in October 2026, part of an 8.1% rise in our pool equipment price index from January 2024 to September 2026. Jandy now files the JE line under its product archive, although Sunplay still listed the JE3000T at $5,699.95 on Nov 3, 2026.
How much does a pool heat pump cost to run per month?
For an uncovered 1,000 sq ft pool held at 80 F, a heat pump cost $199 a month in Phoenix to $430 a month in Chicago at 2025 prices, using DOE’s city heating seasons. Gas cost $486 to $772. With a cover the heat pump drops to $19 to $61 a month. Even at the 50 F COP of 4.0, the heat pump stays cheaper in all five cities.
COP 4.0 is the 50 F AHRI rating of most models; DOE's tables assume a seasonal average COP of 5.0. In DOE's tables a cover cuts these five cities' costs by 79.5% to 90.5%.
Source: DOE Energy Saver city tables (archived); EIA 2025 state prices; PC&S calculation. Download chart data (CSV)
| City | DOE heating season | Gas heater, no cover ($/month) | Heat pump COP 5.0, no cover ($/month) | Heat pump at COP 4.0, no cover ($/month) | Gas heater, cover ($/month) | Heat pump COP 5.0, cover ($/month) | Heat pump cost as % of gas | 2025 gas ($/Mcf) and electricity (cents/kWh) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Miami, FL | Jan 1 to Dec 31 (12 months) | 712 | 212 | 265 | 146 | 44 | 30% | 25.48 / 15.24 |
| Phoenix, AZ | Mar 1 to Oct 31 (8 months) | 486 | 199 | 249 | 46 | 19 | 41% | 18.58 / 15.32 |
| Dallas, TX | Apr 1 to Oct 31 (7 months) | 627 | 249 | 311 | 92 | 36 | 40% | 19.42 / 15.47 |
| Atlanta, GA | Apr 1 to Oct 31 (7 months) | 772 | 277 | 347 | 146 | 52 | 36% | 20.42 / 14.73 |
| Chicago, IL | May 1 to Sep 30 (5 months) | 549 | 430 | 537 | 78 | 61 | 78% | 11.25 / 17.69 |
Source: DOE Energy Saver city cost tables (archived); EIA 2025 natural gas prices; EIA 2025 electricity prices; method from PC&S cost to heat a pool study. Download CSV
The method: DOE publishes season costs for a 1,000 sq ft pool at 80 F in 13 cities. Our cost to heat a pool study converted DOE’s gas figures to the heat the water received, then repriced that heat at each state’s 2025 average gas price for an 82% heater and electricity price for a COP 5.0 heat pump. Dividing the season by DOE’s months gives the monthly figures; the COP 4.0 column multiplies the heat pump cost by 5/4.

| Step | Gas heater | Heat pump | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price, US average, July 2026 | $26.45 per Mcf | 18.31 cents per kWh | EIA |
| Energy in one unit | 1,036,000 Btu per Mcf | 3,412 Btu per kWh | EIA Btu conversions |
| Efficiency | 82% thermal efficiency (federal minimum) | COP 5.0 (DOE table assumption) | 10 CFR 430.32(k); DOE |
| Fuel for 1 million Btu into the water | 1,000,000 / 0.82 / 1,036,000 = 1.177 Mcf | 1,000,000 / (5.0 x 3,412) = 58.6 kWh | PC&S arithmetic |
| Cost per million Btu delivered | $31.14 | $10.73 (COP 4.0: $13.42) | PC&S arithmetic |
| Same, at 2025 US average prices | $18.06 | $10.14 | PC&S research, cost to heat a pool |
Source: EIA natural gas prices; EIA Electric Power Monthly Table 5.6.A; EIA Btu conversions; 10 CFR 430.32(k). Download CSV
Chicago shows where the gap closes. Illinois gas averaged $11.25 per Mcf in 2025 against 17.69 cents per kWh for power, so the heat pump cost 78% of gas instead of 36% in Atlanta. On July 2026 prices the heat pump cost as little as 18.2% of gas heat in Oklahoma and 82.1% in Alaska, the only state where gas was cheaper on 2025 averages.
Pool heat pump vs gas heater: which one should you choose?
Choose a heat pump for long seasons and steady temperatures, and gas for fast heat-ups, spas and cold-air starts. A heat pump delivers heat for about a third of the gas cost at July 2026 US prices but needs roughly two and a half times as long to warm a covered 20,000-gallon pool by 20 F: about 25 hours against 10.
| Factor | Heat pump pool heater | Gas pool heater | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Efficiency measure | COP 4.0 to 7.1 at AHRI points (11 models) | 82% minimum thermal efficiency; 84% to 96% on Pentair models | Maker sheets; 10 CFR 430.32(k); Pentair catalog |
| Cost per million Btu into the water, US July 2026 | $10.73 (COP 5.0) | $31.14 (82%) | EIA; PC&S arithmetic |
| Typical US season, 2025 prices | $327 | $582 | PC&S research from EIA RECS 2020 |
| Hours to raise 20,000 gal by 20 F, covered | 25.1 (140,000 Btu/h at 80 F air); 42.8 at 50 F air | 10.1 (400,000 input at 84%); 16.4 (250,000) | Pentair formula; PC&S loss model |
| Lowest air for heating | 50 F standard Hayward models; 40 F low ambient | No air limit | Hayward LITHTPRO23 |
| Electrical or fuel supply | 208 to 230 V circuit, 38 to 46 A minimum circuit ampacity | Gas line sized by input; about 5 A at 120 V for controls | Maker sheets; Pentair MasterTemp manual |
| Installed cost, swap on existing supply, 2026 | $5,425 to $8,549 | $3,804 to $8,450 | PC&S pool heater installation cost guide |
| Rules | Required as primary heat (or solar) for new California pools from Jan 1, 2026 | Zero NOx required in SCAQMD from Jan 1, 2028 (new) and 2031 (existing) | Title 24 110.4(c); SCAQMD Rule 1146.2 |
Source: maker sheets listed above; EIA; Title 24 Part 6; SCAQMD Rule 1146.2; PC&S installation and loss calculations. Download CSV

The up-front gap is smaller than many guides imply when the pad already has power. Our pool heater installation cost guide puts a heat pump swap at $5,425 to $8,549 and a gas swap at $3,804 to $8,450 in 2026. At the typical US season saving of $255 ($582 gas vs $327 heat pump at 2025 prices), the midpoint difference pays back in 3.4 seasons, or 8.0 if the heat pump needs a new circuit.
| Line | Value | How it is worked out |
|---|---|---|
| Heat pump swap on an existing circuit, midpoint | $6,987 | ($5,425 + $8,549) / 2 |
| Gas heater swap on an existing gas line, midpoint | $6,127 | ($3,804 + $8,450) / 2 |
| Extra up-front cost of the heat pump | $860 | difference |
| Season saving, typical US gas-heated pool, 2025 prices | $255 | $582 gas minus $327 heat pump |
| Simple payback, existing supply | 3.4 seasons | $860 / $255 |
| Simple payback, heat pump needs a new circuit | 8.0 seasons | ($8,162 minus $6,127) / $255 |
Source: PC&S installation cost guide (2026); PC&S cost to heat a pool study (EIA RECS 2020 use, 2025 prices). Download CSV
How long each heater takes for your pool size and start temperature, with heat losses included, is worked out hour by hour in our guide to how long it takes to heat a pool. Rebates can shift the math: Pentair offers up to $200 on select UltraTemp units in 2026, and CenterPoint Energy Indiana pays $350 at COP 5.5 to 5.9 and $800 at COP 6.0 or more (Pentair; CenterPoint).
When does a gas pool heater beat a heat pump?
Gas wins in four cases: air below a heat pump’s 50 F floor, spot heating a spa or weekend pool, a pad with gas but no spare 40 to 60 A circuit, and places where gas is cheap against power, such as Alaska on 2025 prices. Outside those cases, a heat pump delivered pool heat for less in 44 of 45 jurisdictions on 2025 EIA averages.
- Cold starts. Hayward’s standard HeatPro models list 50 F as the lowest heating air temperature; April air averages 49.7 F in Chicago and 47.8 F in Denver under NOAA 1991-2020 normals. Low-ambient units such as the HP31404T heat to 40 F, at the same 85,000 Btu/h 50 F rating.
- Spot heating. A 400,000 Btu/h gas heater at 84% puts 336,000 Btu/h into the water, 2.4 times a 140,000 Btu/h heat pump at 80 F air and 4.0 times the same unit at 50 F air.
- Electrical limits. The rated heat pumps here need a 38 to 46 A minimum circuit ampacity at 208 to 230 V; a gas heater needs a gas line and a small control circuit.
- Prices. On 2025 averages gas delivered heat for $15.26 per million Btu in Alaska against $15.29 for a heat pump, the only reversal among 45 jurisdictions with EIA gas data.
| What some guides and sellers say | Who says it | What the primary source or arithmetic shows |
|---|---|---|
| Heat a pool for about 25% of the cost of heating it with gas | AquaCal brochure AC-2450 | At US average prices a heat pump at COP 5.0 delivered heat for 34.5% of the gas cost in July 2026 ($10.73 vs $31.14) and 56% on 2025 averages ($10.14 vs $18.06). It fell to about 18% only where gas was dear, as in Oklahoma in July 2026 (EIA; PC&S arithmetic). |
| Outputs 5.92x heat for every $1 of electricity | Fibropool FH255 page | 5.92 reads as a COP: heat out per unit of electricity, not per dollar. At 18.31 cents per kWh, $1 buys 5.46 kWh, which at COP 5.92 moves about 110,300 Btu (EIA; PC&S arithmetic). |
| Up to 6 times the efficiency of a standard gas heater | Raypak Crosswind V submittal | Raypak's own 8550 rating is COP 6.0 at 80 F air and 4.2 at 50 F air, so the multiple shrinks in spring; versus an 82% gas heater the energy ratio is 7.3 at COP 6.0 and 5.1 at COP 4.2 (Raypak 100-10009566; 10 CFR 430.32(k)). |
| Heat pumps work best above 50 F | Pinch A Penny guide | Consistent with Hayward's 50 F heating floor for standard HeatPro models; DOE says 45 F to 50 F; Hayward low-ambient models heat down to 40 F (Hayward LITHTPRO23; DOE). |
Source: AquaCal AC-2450; Fibropool FH255 page; Raypak submittal; Pinch A Penny; EIA; PC&S arithmetic. Download CSV
What size heat pump pool heater do you need?
Size a heat pump on its 50 F rating if you swim in spring or fall, and on its 80 F, 63% humidity rating only for summer use. California’s JA16.3 method, which Raypak prints on its submittal, caps the pool at the volume the unit can raise 10 F in 17.5 hours: 16,807 gallons for the 80,000 Btu/h Crosswind V 4550 and 27,311 gallons for the 130,000 Btu/h 8550.
The full sizing math, with DOE’s area x rise x 12 rule, tables for seven pool sizes and April and May air temperatures for 12 cities, is in our guide to what size pool heater you need. The short version for heat pumps: a 16 x 32 ft pool held at 82 F from April in Atlanta needs 115,507 Btu/h, more than any single unit here delivers at 50 F air (best: 90,000).
Pick the water target before the size. DOE gives 78 F to 82 F as typical, and lessons or therapy need warmer water; each extra degree adds 10% to 30% to heating cost per DOE, as our ideal pool temperature guide shows city by city.
Should you buy a heat pump pool heater?
Buy one if you swim most of the season, can run a 40 to 60 A circuit, and start when air averages 50 F or more; pair it with a cover. Choose gas or a hybrid if you heat a spa or weekend pool fast, start in sub-50 F air, or pay cheap gas and dear power. The decision table and flowchart turn those thresholds into a choice.
| If your situation is | Do this | Threshold and source |
|---|---|---|
| You swim May to September and your air averages 60 F or more in your first swim month | Buy a heat pump sized on its 50 F rating | Rated models keep 61% to 66% of output at 50 F (maker sheets); NOAA May normals for most US metros are above 57 F |
| You start in April where April air averages below 50 F (Chicago 49.7 F, Denver 47.8 F) | Pick a low-ambient heat pump rated to 40 F, a gas heater, or a later start | Hayward standard models stop heating at 50 F, low-ambient at 40 F (Hayward) |
| You heat a spa or the pool only on weekends | Gas, or a hybrid such as a heat pump plus gas backup | 20,000 gal +20 F: about 10 hours with 400,000 Btu/h gas vs 25 with a 140,000 Btu/h heat pump, covered (PC&S loss model) |
| You build a new pool in California | Plan a heat pump or solar as primary heat, and a cover | Title 24 Section 110.4(b)3 and 110.4(c), permits applied from Jan 1, 2026 |
| You are in the South Coast AQMD and replacing a gas heater | Price a heat pump now; a new gas heater must be zero NOx from 2028 (new) or 2031 (existing) | SCAQMD Rule 1146.2 |
| No 208 to 230 V circuit of 40 to 60 A reaches the pad | Get an electrician's quote first; a new circuit adds $250 to $2,100 | Maker minimum circuit ampacity 38 to 46 A; Angi via PC&S installation cost guide |
| Your gas is cheap and power dear (Illinois 2025: $11.25 per Mcf, 17.69 cents per kWh) | Compare per month before buying; Chicago's heat pump saved 22% vs gas, not 60% to 70% | DOE Chicago season repriced at 2025 Illinois prices (PC&S research) |
| You already own a gas heater that works | Add a cover first: it cut heating cost 76.2% to 92.1% in DOE's 13 city tables | DOE Energy Saver city tables (archived) |
Source: maker sheets; NOAA 1991-2020 normals; Title 24; SCAQMD Rule 1146.2; PC&S research. Download CSV

Ask installers three things in writing: the model’s 50 F AHRI rating against your pool’s heat need, the breaker and wire size from the maker’s sheet, and whether the quote includes a pad, a disconnect within sight of the unit and a bypass valve for flows above the maker’s maximum (75 gpm on HeatPro, 70 gpm on AquaCal).
How we compiled this
We opened 14 primary documents in November 2026: 10 spec sheets, manuals and product pages from Hayward, Pentair, Jandy, AquaCal, Raypak and Fibropool, and four archived DOE Energy Saver pages. EIA prices, 10 CFR 430.32, California Title 20 and Title 24, and SCAQMD Rule 1146.2 figures are reused from our research reports, which cite them. Prices are four retailer listings captured Nov 3, 2026 plus two captures from our equipment price index. We did not test any heater; every cost and time figure is our arithmetic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the downsides of using a heat pump pool heater?
Speed, cold air and wiring. A 140,000 Btu/h heat pump takes about 25 hours to raise a covered 20,000-gallon pool by 20 F, against 10 for a 400,000 Btu/h gas heater. Output falls to 61% to 66% at 50 F air, standard Hayward models stop heating at 50 F, and most units need a 208 to 230 V, 40 to 60 A circuit.
Do heat pump pool heaters work?
Yes, when the air is mild. DOE says they work efficiently while outdoor air stays above 45 F to 50 F. At 80 F air the 11 rated models here deliver 5.7 to 7.1 Btu of heat per Btu of electricity; at 50 F air that falls to 4.0 to 4.2, still about five times an 82% gas heater’s ratio of heat to fuel.
What is the cheapest way to heat a swimming pool?
A cover first: DOE’s city tables show it cutting heating cost by 76.2% to 92.1%. Among heaters, solar collectors burn no fuel, and a heat pump delivered heat for $10.73 per million Btu at July 2026 US prices against $31.14 for an 82% gas heater. Our solar pool heater guide prices collectors.
How long does it take a heat pump to heat a 10,000 gallon pool?
About 6 hours for a 10 F rise and 12 hours for 20 F with a 140,000 Btu/h heat pump at 80 F air and a cover, using Pentair’s formula (gallons x 8.34 x rise / output) plus a 1 F per day loss. At 50 F air the same unit, rated 85,000 Btu/h, needs about 20 hours for 20 F.
Is a pool heat pump cheaper to run than a gas heater?
Almost everywhere. On 2025 averages a COP 5.0 heat pump delivered heat for less than an 82% gas heater in 44 of 45 jurisdictions with EIA gas data; Alaska was the exception. Uncovered at 80 F, a heat pump cost $277 a month in Atlanta against $772 for gas, but the gap shrank to $430 vs $549 in Chicago. DOE puts the saving from covering the pool when not in use at 50% to 70% of that bill; what a basic bubble blanket achieves is tested in our do solar pool covers work guide.
What breaker size does a pool heat pump need?
Follow the maker’s sheet. The Hayward HeatPro HP21404T lists a 42 A minimum circuit ampacity with 50 A minimum and 60 A maximum overload protection; Pentair’s UltraTemp 140 lists 43 A, a 50 A recommended fuse and 70 A maximum; Raypak’s Crosswind V 8550 lists 46 A and a 60 A recommended breaker, all at 208 to 230 V.
Sources
- Hayward Industries. HeatPro Series sell sheet LITHTPRO23 (AHRI 1160 ratings). Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Hayward Industries. HeatPro HP31005T manual 51300056501 Rev G. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Pentair. 2025-2026 Pool Product Catalog, heaters and heat pumps section. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Pentair. UltraTemp heat pump installation and user's guide. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Pentair. 2025-2026 catalog, Engineering Data (time-to-heat formula, p. 530). Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Zodiac Pool Systems (Jandy). JE heat pump installation and operation manual H0408600 Rev F. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- AquaCal AutoPilot. HeatWave SuperQuiet brochure AC-2450 V8 (archived copy). Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Raypak. Crosswind V product submittal 100-10009566 Rev 01. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Fibropool. FH255 heat pump product page. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- U.S. Department of Energy. Energy Saver: Heat Pump Swimming Pool Heaters (archived Jan 1, 2026). Accessed 2026-11-03.
- U.S. Department of Energy. Energy Saver: Gas Pool Heaters, city cost tables (archived Jan 1, 2026). Accessed 2026-11-03.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration. Natural gas prices, residential, monthly and annual. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration. Electric Power Monthly Table 5.6.A. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration. British thermal units (Btu) conversions. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- eCFR. 10 CFR 430.32 energy conservation standards (pool heaters). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- California Energy Commission (via Cornell LII). Title 20 Section 1605.3. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- California Energy Commission. 2025 Building Energy Efficiency Standards, Title 24 Part 6. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- South Coast Air Quality Management District. Rule 1146.2. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Walmart.com. Hayward W3HP21404T listing. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Leslie's. Raypak Crosswind V 8550 listing (Wayback capture Jun 30, 2026). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- SwimmingPoolSupplyUSA. Pentair UltraTemp 140 460964 listing. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- EZ Pools. AquaCal SQ145 and SQ225 listings. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Sunplay. Jandy JE3000T listing. Accessed 2026-11-03.
- Pentair. Pentair product rebates 2026. Accessed 2026-11-03.
Related pages
Get Quotes From Licensed Local Pool Pros
Tell us what you need and your ZIP code. We match you with pool companies that cover your area.