
Pool Filter Types: Sand vs Cartridge vs DE Compared by Spec, Water Use and 10-Year Cost
Pool filter types come in three kinds: sand, cartridge and DE, rated at 20 to 40, 10 and 5 microns by EPA. Over 10 years sand cost least in our model, $1,288 to $1,562.
- ✓15 models from spec sheetsArea, rated flow, pressure and dated prices for Hayward, Pentair and Intex filters.
- ✓Codes, not marketingMicron claims checked against NSF/ANSI 50, the 2024 Model Aquatic Health Code and Title 24.
- ✓IndependentPC&S sells no filters or media. We connect owners with licensed pool service companies.
Key takeaways
- EPA’s WaterSense pool guide lists sand filters at 20 to 40 microns, cartridges at 10 and DE at 5, but NSF/ANSI 50, the standard filters are certified to, tests turbidity reduction rather than particle size (EPA WaterSense, 2022; Intertek NSF/ANSI 50 notice).
- The 2024 Model Aquatic Health Code caps public-pool filtration at 15 gpm per sq ft for sand, 2 for DE and 0.375 for cartridges, while Hayward rates its residential sand filters at 20 gpm per sq ft, the maximum NSF rating (CDC MAHC 2024; Hayward ProSeries sell sheet).
- One backwash and rinse sends 116 to 347 gallons to waste on a Hayward S244T or Pentair TR60, so weekly backwashing uses 6,032 to 18,044 gallons a year, against 270 to 450 gallons of hose water for a cartridge filter (PC&S arithmetic from maker manuals).
- Flux-calcined pool DE contains 35 to 50% crystalline silica (cristobalite), and its safety data sheet carries a may-cause-cancer-by-inhalation warning (EP Minerals Celapool SDS).
- Over 10 years our model puts a Hayward S244T sand filter at $1,288 to $1,562, a Pro-Grid DE4820 at $2,468 to $3,092 and a SwimClear C4030 cartridge filter at $2,610 to $3,393, media and water included (PC&S price panel).
What are the different types of pool filters?
Residential pools use three pool filter types: sand, cartridge and DE (diatomaceous earth). Sand and DE filters are cleaned by backwashing; cartridges are pulled out and hosed. EPA’s WaterSense guide adds glass media, which goes into a sand filter tank, and every certified filter of any type must pass the same NSF/ANSI 50 turbidity test.
| Number | What it means | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 20 to 40, 10 and 5 microns | Smallest particle EPA's WaterSense guide lists for sand, cartridge and DE filters | U.S. EPA WaterSense (2022), citing a 2010 study |
| 70% in 5 turnovers | Turbidity cut every filter must reach in the NSF/ANSI 50 test, from 45 NTU of silica | Intertek notice on NSF/ANSI/CAN 50 (effective July 1, 2023) |
| 15, 2 and 0.375 gpm per sq ft | Highest public-pool filtration rate for sand, DE and cartridge filters | CDC Model Aquatic Health Code 2024 |
| 20 gpm per sq ft | Rate Hayward uses for residential sand filter flow ratings, the maximum NSF rating | Hayward ProSeries sell sheet (2024) |
| 116 to 347 gallons | Water one sand backwash and rinse sends to waste on the S244T and TR60 | PC&S arithmetic from Hayward and Pentair manuals |
| 35 to 50% | Crystalline silica (cristobalite) in flux-calcined pool DE | EP Minerals Celapool SDS |
| $689, $1,539, $1,819 | 2026 median listed price: sand, DE and cartridge filters for inground pools | PC&S price panel |
| $1,288 to $3,393 | 10-year cost range across the three reference filters in our model | PC&S arithmetic |
Sources: U.S. EPA WaterSense (2022); Intertek NSF/ANSI/CAN 50 notice; CDC MAHC 2024; Hayward ProSeries sell sheet; EP Minerals Celapool SDS; PC&S price panel; PC&S arithmetic. Download CSV
A sand filter pushes water down through a bed of No. 20 silica sand graded 0.45 to 0.55 mm; a Hayward ProSeries S244T holds 300 lb of it (Hayward ProSeries manual). A cartridge filter such as the Hayward SwimClear C4030 spreads 425 sq ft of pleated polyester across a four-element cluster (Hayward C4030 page). A DE filter coats fabric grids with powder before each run: 6.0 lb on a 48 sq ft Hayward Pro-Grid DE4820 (Hayward Pro-Grid manual).
| Feature | Sand | Cartridge | DE (diatomaceous earth) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Filter medium | No. 20 silica sand, 0.45 to 0.55 mm | Pleated polyester elements | DE powder coated on fabric grids | Hayward ProSeries manual; Hayward C4030 page; Pentair FNS Plus guide |
| Smallest particle, EPA figure | 20 to 40 microns | 10 microns (can vary) | 5 microns | U.S. EPA WaterSense (2022) |
| Public-pool rate limit (MAHC 2024) | 15 gpm per sq ft | 0.375 gpm per sq ft (operating) | 2 gpm per sq ft (pressure) | CDC MAHC 2024 |
| Typical residential rating | 15 to 20 gpm per sq ft | 0.29 to 0.38 gpm per sq ft | 2 to 2.5 gpm per sq ft | Hayward and Pentair manuals (model table below) |
| How it is cleaned | Backwash at 8 to 10 psi over clean | Remove and hose cartridges at about 10 psi over clean | Backwash, then recoat with fresh DE | Hayward ProSeries and Pro-Grid manuals; Pentair guides |
| Water per cleaning | 116 to 347 gallons | About 30 to 50 gallons of hose water | 224 gallons (DE4820) | PC&S arithmetic; City of Thousand Oaks hose rate |
| Media life, EPA | 3 to 6 years | 2 to 4 years | Grids 2 to 3 years | U.S. EPA WaterSense (2022) |
| Media price, Oct 2026 | $13.95 per 50 lb bag | $95.99 per CX880XRE cartridge | $45.95 per 50 lb of DE; $141.99 grid set | Dave's Pool Store; All Pool Filters 4 Less |
| Median filter price, 2026 | $689 (22 to 30 inch) | $1,819 (325 to 525 sq ft) | $1,539 (48 to 60 sq ft) | PC&S price panel |
Sources: Hayward ProSeries manual; Hayward C4030 page; Pentair FNS Plus guide (2025); Pentair Clean & Clear Plus guide (2025); Hayward Pro-Grid manual; EPA WaterSense; CDC MAHC 2024; City of Thousand Oaks; Dave's Pool Store; All Pool Filters 4 Less; PC&S price panel. Download CSV
Price separates them before anything else. The 2026 median listed price was $689 for a 22 to 30 inch inground sand filter, $1,539 for a 48 to 60 sq ft DE filter and $1,819 for a 325 to 525 sq ft cartridge filter across Leslie’s, Home Depot and Walmart.com listings, as tracked in our pool equipment price index.
How small a particle does each pool filter type catch?
The published answer is 20 to 40 microns for sand, about 10 for cartridges and about 5 for DE, from EPA’s 2022 WaterSense guide, which cites a 2010 consultant report. Seven sources we checked put sand at 20 to 100 microns and DE at 1 to 5. None of these figures comes from NSF/ANSI 50, which certifies filters on turbidity reduction instead. Set against pollen grain sizes, part of the ragweed and mulberry range passes a sand filter, as our guide to pollen in pool water shows.
A single point (low equals high) means the source gave one number.
Source: U.S. EPA WaterSense (2022); Hayward (May 2023); Pinch A Penny; Beltway Pools (May 2026); Chloramine Consulting; All Filters. Accessed October 27, 2026. Download chart data (CSV)
| Who says it | Sand | Cartridge | DE | What the figure rests on |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| U.S. EPA WaterSense guide (2022) | 20 to 40 microns | 10 microns (can vary) | 5 microns | Cites a 2010 Koeller and Hoffman report; glass 5 microns cites a 2021 source |
| Hayward blog (May 2023) | 20 to 40 | 10 to 20 | 3 to 5 | Maker article; no test method given |
| Pinch A Penny buyer's guide | 20 to 30 | 10 to 20 | 3 to 5 | Retailer guide; no test method given |
| All Filters blog | 20 to 40 | Not stated | About 3 | Retailer blog; no test method given |
| Beltway Pools (May 2026) | 20 to 100 (table), 20 to 40 (text) | 10 to 30 | Below 5 | Builder article; says ratings vary by maker |
| Chloramine Consulting | 20 to 30 | 8 to 12 | As small as 1 | Consultant blog citing an Orenda graphic |
| The Pool Factory | 20 | 10 | Not stated | Retailer page |
| NSF/ANSI 50 (the certification standard) | No micron rating | No micron rating | No micron rating | Turbidity test: 45 NTU of silica #140 cut by 70% within 5 tank turnovers |
Sources: EPA WaterSense (2022); Hayward (May 2023); Pinch A Penny; All Filters; Beltway Pools; Chloramine Consulting; The Pool Factory; Intertek NSF/ANSI/CAN 50 notice. All accessed Oct 27, 2026. Download CSV
NSF/ANSI 50 fills a test tank, adds silica #140 to 45 NTU (plus or minus 5) and requires the filter to cut turbidity by 70% or more by the fifth tank turnover, each turnover taking no more than 30 minutes at the filter’s maximum design flow (Intertek notice on NSF/ANSI/CAN 50, effective July 1, 2023). Writing in Aquatics International (2017), Sung Choe called it a suspended-solids removal test measured by turbidity, and an often misunderstood one.
Fineness also shifts with use. Hayward’s filter-types article says a sand filter becomes increasingly more efficient as it continues to filter, and gives cartridges 10 to 20 microns, a wider band than EPA’s single figure of 10. Treat a micron number as a rough ranking of sand, cartridge and DE, not as a spec to compare two cartridge brands.
Which pool filter is better, sand or cartridge?
Sand vs cartridge pool filter comes down to water, price and flow. A sand filter costs less, $689 median against $1,819 in 2026, but each backwash sends 116 to 347 gallons to waste; a cartridge is hosed off instead. In our 10-year model the Hayward S244T sand filter costs $1,288 to $1,562 and the SwimClear C4030 $2,610 to $3,393.
| Filter and case | Gallons per backwash or cleaning | Events per year | Basis for frequency | Gallons per year | Water cost per year at $8.54 per 1,000 gal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sand, Hayward S244T (backwash at the MAHC 15 gpm per sq ft floor) | 116 to 140 | 52 | EPA: backwash once per week | 6,032 to 7,280 | $51.51 to $62.17 |
| Sand, Pentair Triton TR60 (63 gpm) | 221 to 347 | 52 | EPA: backwash once per week | 11,492 to 18,044 | $98.14 to $154.10 |
| DE, Hayward Pro-Grid DE4820 (96 gpm) | 224 | 6.5 to 13 | EPA: backwash every 4 to 8 weeks | 1,456 to 2,912 | $12.43 to $24.87 |
| Cartridge hose-off (10 minutes at 3 to 5 gpm) | 30 to 50 | 9 | Simple Green: monthly in summer, every other month in winter | 270 to 450 | $2.31 to $3.84 |
Sources: gallons per backwash from our backwash guide (Hayward and Pentair manuals, MAHC 5.7.2.2.2); frequencies from EPA WaterSense and Simple Green; hose flow from City of Thousand Oaks; water rate from PC&S pool evaporation research; PC&S arithmetic (10 minutes of hosing per cartridge cleaning is our estimate). Download CSV
At EPA’s planning rate of one backwash a week, a Hayward S244T sends 6,032 to 7,280 gallons a year to waste and a Pentair TR60 sends 11,492 to 18,044, while nine hose-offs of a cartridge filter use 270 to 450 gallons at the 3 to 5 gpm a hand-held hose delivers (City of Thousand Oaks). EPA’s guide cites a California estimate that 23% of quantifiable pool water use goes to filter backwashes (EPA WaterSense).
Treat 52 backwashes a year as a ceiling, not a schedule. Pentair’s Triton guide says not to backwash solely on a timed basis such as every three days and to backwash at 10 psi over the post-backwash reading (Pentair Triton guide). The full routine, with times by model, is in our guide to backwashing a pool filter.
- Flow. Hayward rates a 24 inch ProSeries S244T at 62 gpm and a SwimClear C4030 at 150 gpm, so a large pump at high speed can outrun a small sand filter.
- Media life. EPA puts sand at 3 to 6 years and cartridges at 2 to 4, and four Hayward CX880XRE cartridges at the October 2026 listed price of $95.99 each come to $383.96, against $83.70 for 300 lb of sand.
- Local rules. Phoenix keeps backwash out of the street, alley and right of way, and San Diego County keeps it out of storm drains; a cartridge filter sidesteps both.
- Cleaning work. A cartridge cleaning means opening the tank, which Pentair’s Clean & Clear Plus guide schedules at about 10 psi over the starting pressure.
The cartridge routine, from hosing angle to degreasing soaks, is laid out in our guide on how to clean a pool filter.
What is a DE pool filter, and is the powder safe to handle?
A DE pool filter coats fabric grids with diatomaceous earth, a powder of fossil diatoms, at 1.0 to 1.25 lb per 10 sq ft of grid, and EPA lists it at 5 microns. Pool DE is usually flux-calcined, and the Celapool safety data sheet lists 35 to 50% crystalline silica (cristobalite) with a cancer-by-inhalation warning, so handling and disposal rules matter.
Hayward’s Pro-Grid manual calls for 3.0 lb of DE on a DE2420, 6.0 lb on a DE4820 and 7.5 lb on a DE6020; Pentair’s FNS Plus guide calls for 3.6, 4.8 and 6 lb on its 36, 48 and 60 sq ft models. Each backwash flushes the coat out, so at EPA’s every 4 to 8 weeks a DE4820 uses 39 to 78 lb a year, $35.84 to $71.68 at $45.95 per 50 lb (Dave's Pool Store, Oct 2026).

| Jurisdiction or code | Rule on DE and filter waste | Applies to | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| CDC Model Aquatic Health Code 2024, 4.11.6.4 | Separation tank required before discharging DE filter backwash; perlite or cellulose may go to the sanitary sewer unless the health authority says otherwise | Public pools in adopting jurisdictions | CDC MAHC 2024 |
| New York, 10 NYCRR 6-1.11 | DE backwash discharges to the sewer through a separation tank; DE filters run at 2 gpm per sq ft or less with body feed | Regulated public pools in New York | New York State regulation |
| City of Surprise, Arizona | Use a separation tank for DE and cellulose filters; rinse cartridges in a sink, tub or over a lawn; never backwash to the street or a retention basin | Homes | City of Surprise flyer |
| County of San Diego, California | No filter rinse water, backwash or filter media (DE, sand) to the storm drain | Homes and businesses | County of San Diego (June 5, 2026) |
| City of Phoenix, Arizona | Reuse backwash on landscaping; backwash may not go to the street, alley or right of way; sewer clean-out at 12 gpm or less | Homes | City of Phoenix |
Sources: CDC MAHC 2024, 4.11.6.4; 10 NYCRR 6-1.11; City of Surprise, AZ; County of San Diego (June 5, 2026); City of Phoenix. Accessed Oct 27, 2026. Download CSV
The 2024 Model Aquatic Health Code requires a separation tank before DE backwash leaves a public pool (4.11.6.4), New York sends DE backwash to the sewer through one, and the City of Surprise, Arizona asks homeowners to use one too. Ask your city’s sewer or stormwater office whether spent DE may enter the sanitary sewer before you buy a DE filter.
How do 15 pool filter models compare on area, flow and pressure?
Across 15 Hayward, Pentair and Intex models, rated flow runs from 40.8 gpm on an Intex SF60110-2 pump combo to 150 gpm on the SwimClear C4030 and C5030, and every inground model is rated for 50 psi. Flow per sq ft clusters near 20 for sand, 2 to 2.5 for DE and 0.29 to 0.38 for cartridges, which is how to match a filter to a pump.
| Type | Model | Filter area (sq ft) | Rated flow (gpm) | Rated flow per sq ft (gpm) | Public-pool limit, MAHC 2024 (gpm per sq ft) | Flow at that limit (gpm) | Max working pressure (psi) | Listed price (USD) | Price listing | Spec source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sand | Intex Krystal Clear SF60110-2 (above-ground pump combo) | 1.44 | 40.8 | 28.4 | 15 | 21.6 | 30 | Not in PC&S price panel | Intex owner manual, p. 8 (2,450 GPH maximum) | |
| Sand | Hayward ProSeries S220T | 2.64 | 52 | 19.7 | 15 | 39.6 | 50 | 669 | Leslie's, Feb 2026 | Hayward ProSeries sell sheet LITPROTM0SS24 (2024) |
| Sand | Hayward ProSeries S244T | 3.14 | 62 | 19.7 | 15 | 47.1 | 50 | 689 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Hayward ProSeries sell sheet LITPROTM0SS24 (2024) |
| Sand | Pentair Triton TR60 | 3.1 | 63 | 20.3 | 15 | 46.5 | 50 | 1,189 | Leslie's, June 2026 | Pentair Triton guide, Table 1 |
| Sand | Pentair Triton TR100 | 4.9 | 74 | 15.1 | 15 | 73.5 | 50 | 1,449 | Leslie's, May 2025 | Pentair Triton guide, Table 1 (rated at 15 gpm per sq ft) |
| Cartridge | Hayward SwimClear C3030 | 325 | 122 | 0.375 | 0.375 | 121.9 | 50 | 1,599 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Hayward SwimClear manual ISC2031EF Rev B |
| Cartridge | Hayward SwimClear C4030 | 425 | 150 | 0.353 | 0.375 | 159.4 | 50 | 1,819 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Hayward SwimClear manual ISC2031EF Rev B |
| Cartridge | Hayward SwimClear C5030 | 525 | 150 | 0.286 | 0.375 | 196.9 | 50 | 2,249 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Hayward SwimClear manual ISC2031EF Rev B |
| Cartridge | Pentair Clean & Clear Plus CCP320 | 320 | 120 | 0.375 | 0.375 | 120 | 50 | Not in PC&S price panel | Pentair Clean & Clear Plus guide (2025), p. 12 | |
| Cartridge | Pentair Clean & Clear Plus CCP420 | 420 | 150 | 0.357 | 0.375 | 157.5 | 50 | Not in PC&S price panel | Pentair Clean & Clear Plus guide (2025), p. 12 | |
| DE | Hayward Pro-Grid DE2420 | 24 | 48 | 2.0 | 2 | 48 | 50 | Not in PC&S price panel | Hayward Pro-Grid manual ISDE2423EF Rev E | |
| DE | Hayward Pro-Grid DE4820 | 48 | 96 | 2.0 | 2 | 96 | 50 | 1,559 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Hayward Pro-Grid manual ISDE2423EF Rev E |
| DE | Hayward Pro-Grid DE6020 | 60 | 120 | 2.0 | 2 | 120 | 50 | Not in PC&S price panel | Hayward Pro-Grid manual ISDE2423EF Rev E | |
| DE | Pentair FNS Plus FNSP48 | 48 | 120 | 2.5 | 2 | 96 | 50 | 1,379 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Pentair FNS Plus guide (2025), p. 13 |
| DE | Pentair FNS Plus FNSP60 | 60 | 150 | 2.5 | 2 | 120 | 50 | 1,519 | Leslie's, Sept 2026 | Pentair FNS Plus guide (2025), p. 13 |
Sources: Hayward ProSeries sell sheet (2024); Pentair Triton guide; Hayward SwimClear manual; Pentair Clean & Clear Plus guide (2025); Hayward Pro-Grid manual; Pentair FNS Plus guide (2025); Intex SF manual; limits from CDC MAHC 2024; prices from the PC&S price panel (archived retailer pages); PC&S arithmetic. Download CSV
Source: Hayward ProSeries sell sheet LITPROTM0SS24, SwimClear ISC2031EF Rev B and Pro-Grid ISDE2423EF Rev E manuals; Pentair Triton, Clean & Clear Plus (2025) and FNS Plus (2025) guides; Intex SF owner manual. Accessed October 27, 2026. Download chart data (CSV)
Residential ratings run above public-pool limits. Hayward bases its ProSeries flows on 20 gpm per sq ft, which its sell sheet calls the maximum allowable NSF rating, while the 2024 Model Aquatic Health Code designs public sand filters at no more than 15 (MAHC 4.7.2.2.3.1). Pentair rates the FNS Plus FNSP48 at 120 gpm, 2.5 gpm per sq ft, against MAHC’s 2 for pressure DE filters, so at code rate the same filter would carry 96 gpm.

California applies public-pool math to new home pools. The 2025 Energy Code, section 150.0(p), sizes residential filters at the pump’s maximum flow with factors of 15 for sand, 2 for DE and 0.375 for cartridges (Energy Code Ace fact sheet). Under that rule a Hayward S244T covers 47.1 gpm rather than its 62 gpm rating, and a SwimClear C4030 covers 159.4 gpm. Pump flow at your settings is worked out in our guide on how long to run a pool pump. To size the pump to the filter and pipe in the first place, use our pool pump size calculator.
Pressure ratings are uniform: 50 psi for every inground model, the minimum NSF/ANSI 50 sets for any pressure filter, and 30 psi (2 bar) for Intex’s above-ground SF series (Intex manual). NSF’s test holds a tank at 1.5 times its rated pressure for 300 seconds, cycles it 20,000 times to 30 psi and bursts it at twice rated pressure (Aquatics International).
What does each pool filter type cost over 10 years?
In our 10-year model a Hayward S244T sand filter costs $1,288 to $1,562, a Pro-Grid DE4820 $2,468 to $3,092 and a SwimClear C4030 cartridge filter $2,610 to $3,393. The model adds the September 2026 filter price, media at EPA’s replacement intervals, DE powder, and backwash or rinse water at $8.54 per 1,000 gallons; labor and pump power are left out.
| Filter type | Reference model | Filter price (USD) | Media replacements, 10 years | DE powder, 10 years | Backwash or rinse water, 10 years | 10-year total, low | 10-year total, high | Arithmetic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sand | Hayward ProSeries S244T (62 gpm) | 689 | $83.70 to $251.10 | n/a | $515.13 to $621.71 | $1,287.83 | $1,561.81 | 1 to 3 sand changes (EPA 3 to 6 year life) x 6 bags x $13.95 = $83.70 each; 520 backwashes (weekly) x 116 to 140 gal = 60,320 to 72,800 gal |
| Cartridge | Hayward SwimClear C4030 (150 gpm) | 1,819 | $767.92 to $1,535.84 | n/a | $23.06 to $38.43 | $2,609.98 | $3,393.27 | 2 to 4 cartridge sets (EPA 2 to 4 year life) x 4 x $95.99 = $383.96 each; 90 hose-offs x 30 to 50 gal = 2,700 to 4,500 gal |
| DE | Hayward Pro-Grid DE4820 (96 gpm) | 1,559 | $425.97 to $567.96 | $358.41 to $716.82 | $124.34 to $248.68 | $2,467.72 | $3,092.46 | 3 to 4 grid sets (EPA 2 to 3 year grid life) x $141.99; 65 to 130 backwashes (every 4 to 8 weeks) x 224 gal = 14,560 to 29,120 gal; 65 to 130 recoats x 6.0 lb x $0.919 per lb = 390 to 780 lb |
Sources: filter prices from the PC&S price panel (Leslie’s, Sept 2026); media from Dave's Pool Store, All Pool Filters 4 Less (CX880XRE) and All Pool Filters 4 Less (FS-2004); lifetimes and frequencies from EPA WaterSense; DE charge from the Hayward Pro-Grid manual; water at $8.54 per 1,000 gallons from PC&S evaporation research; PC&S arithmetic. Download CSV
Excludes labor, pump electricity, chemicals and a DE separation tank.
Source: PC&S model from the PC&S price panel (Leslie's, Sept 2026), Oct 27, 2026 media listings, U.S. EPA WaterSense media lives and Hayward manuals. Download chart data (CSV)
| Item | Pack | Listed price (USD) | Price per lb or per set | Seller | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No. 20 silica pool filter sand | 50 lb bag | 13.95 | $0.279 per lb | Dave's Pool Store | Oct 27, 2026 |
| No. 20 silica pool filter sand | 50 lb bag | 14.35 | $0.287 per lb | Waterline Technologies | Oct 27, 2026 |
| Recycled glass filter media | 50 lb bag | 35.09 | $0.702 per lb | PoolBlu (FG50) | Oct 27, 2026 |
| Vitroclean glass filter media | 50 lb bag | 42.95 | $0.859 per lb | Dave's Pool Store | Oct 27, 2026 |
| Pool grade DE powder | 25 lb bag | 19.95 | $0.798 per lb | Dave's Pool Store | Oct 27, 2026 |
| Pool grade DE powder | 50 lb bag | 45.95 | $0.919 per lb | Dave's Pool Store | Oct 27, 2026 |
| Hayward CX880XRE cartridge (C4030 holds 4) | 1 cartridge | 95.99 | $383.96 per set of 4 | All Pool Filters 4 Less | Oct 27, 2026 |
| Unicel FS-2004 DE grid set for Pro-Grid DE4820 (7 full, 1 partial) | 1 set | 141.99 | $141.99 per set | All Pool Filters 4 Less | Oct 27, 2026 |
Sources: Dave's Pool Store sand; Waterline Technologies; PoolBlu; Dave's Pool Store glass; Dave's Pool Store DE; All Pool Filters 4 Less CX880XRE; All Pool Filters 4 Less FS-2004. Download CSV
Three inputs move the totals most. Backwash frequency drives the sand line: water is $515.13 to $621.71 of its 10-year cost at one backwash a week. Cartridge life drives the cartridge line: four sets at EPA’s 2-year end cost $1,535.84. DE recoats drive the DE line: each of 65 to 130 backwashes takes 6.0 lb of powder.
If a service company looks after the filter, add its cleaning charge to these lines; our pool service cost survey lists what companies in 20 cities charge.
Is glass or zeolite media a good alternative to sand?
Glass media goes into an existing sand filter. EPA lists it at 5 microns with a 7 to 15 year life, against 20 to 40 microns and 3 to 6 years for sand. It costs more per pound, $35.09 to $42.95 per 50 lb bag against $13.95 for sand in October 2026, but less weight goes in. We found no primary-source test data for zeolite.
Intex’s sand filter pump manual lists glass loads of 35, 55 and 84 lb where No. 20 silica sand would be 50, 77 and 121 lb, about 0.70 of the weight (Intex manual). Dave’s Pool Store, which sells Vitroclean, uses 0.80 and charts 168 lb of glass plus 72 lb of pebble for a Hayward S244T (Dave's Pool Store). Those 4 glass bags list at $171.80, against $83.70 for the 6 bags of sand on the S244T label.
The seller says Vitroclean lasts 50% longer than sand, generally 7 to 10 years, a claim narrower than EPA’s 7 to 15. Zeolite media is also sold as a sand replacement, but neither EPA’s WaterSense table nor the filter manuals we read list it, so it is left out of the cost model. Hayward’s ProSeries manual specifies 0.45 to 0.55 mm silica sand; ask the filter maker in writing whether another medium changes the warranty. Maker glass and zeolite ratios, about 0.70 of the sand weight for Intex glass and 0.64 to 0.67 for Jandy’s Zeobrite, are tabled in our guide on how to change sand in a pool filter.
Which pool filter type should you choose?
Pick on four facts: where backwash water may go, your pump’s maximum flow, how much powder handling you accept, and 10-year cost. Cartridges suit pools where backwash has nowhere legal to go, DE suits owners who want EPA’s finest rating and accept silica handling, and sand suits owners who want the lowest cost in our model, $1,288 to $1,562 over 10 years.
| If your situation is | Do this | Why (source) |
|---|---|---|
| Your city bars backwash from the street and you have no sewer clean-out or yard that can absorb it | Choose a cartridge filter | Cartridges are hosed off, not backwashed (EPA WaterSense); San Diego County and Phoenix restrict backwash discharge |
| You want the finest filtration and accept handling powder | Choose DE and buy a NIOSH approved mask | EPA lists DE at 5 microns; pool DE is 35 to 50% cristobalite (Celapool SDS) |
| You want the lowest 10-year cost | Choose sand | $1,288 to $1,562 in our model against $2,468 or more for DE and cartridge |
| You build a new pool in California | Size the filter at 15 (sand), 2 (DE) or 0.375 (cartridge) gpm per sq ft at the pump's maximum flow | 2025 Title 24, Part 6, 150.0(p) via Energy Code Ace |
| Your pump moves more than 62 gpm | Skip a 24 inch sand filter such as the S244T; pick a C4030, DE6020 or FNSP48 class filter | Hayward and Pentair rated flows in the model table |
| You have a sand filter and want longer media life | Consider glass media at about 0.8 times the sand weight | EPA: glass 7 to 15 years vs sand 3 to 6; Vitroclean seller chart |
| Your DE grids or cartridges tear or stop recovering after cleaning | Replace the elements, not the tank | Grid set $141.99; CX880XRE $95.99 each (Oct 2026 listings) |
Sources: EPA WaterSense; Celapool SDS; Energy Code Ace (Title 24); County of San Diego; City of Phoenix; Hayward and Pentair manuals; listings in the media price table; PC&S model. Download CSV

When should you call a pro? When a new filter type means re-plumbing or a new backwash line. Ask the installer three things: the filter’s rated flow against your pump’s maximum flow, where backwash or rinse water will discharge under your city’s rules, and whether the price includes the first media charge, 300 lb of sand for an S244T or 6.0 lb of DE for a DE4820.
Weekly gauge readings and basket checks fit into the routine in our guide to maintaining a pool.
How we compiled this
In October 2026 we read 10 filter maker documents (Hayward’s ProSeries manual and sell sheet, SwimClear and Pro-Grid manuals, C4030 page and filter-types article; Pentair’s Triton, Clean & Clear Plus and FNS Plus guides; Intex’s sand filter pump manual), CDC’s 2024 Model Aquatic Health Code, the EPA WaterSense pool guide, an NSF/ANSI 50 update notice, California’s Title 24 pool fact sheet, New York’s pool code, OSHA’s silica standard, a DE safety data sheet and 4 local government pages. Prices come from our price panel and 7 retailer listings checked October 27, 2026. We tested no filters; micron figures are quoted from their publishers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the five main types of filters?
For pools, the five media in use are sand, glass, cartridge, DE and perlite or cellulose precoat. EPA’s WaterSense guide lists the first four with micron and lifetime figures, and the 2024 Model Aquatic Health Code treats perlite and cellulose as precoat media whose backwash may go to the sanitary sewer, while DE backwash needs a separation tank (CDC MAHC 4.11.6.4).
What is the best type of pool filtration system?
None wins on every measure. DE has EPA’s finest rating at 5 microns, a cartridge uses the least water because it is never backwashed, and sand had the lowest 10-year cost in our model at $1,288 to $1,562. Every certified filter passes the same NSF/ANSI 50 test, a 70% turbidity cut within five tank turnovers (Intertek).
Which pool filter is better, sand or cartridge?
Cartridge if water or discharge rules matter: it is hosed off with about 30 to 50 gallons instead of a 116 to 347 gallon backwash. Sand if cost matters: a $689 median price in 2026 against $1,819, and $1,288 to $1,562 over 10 years against $2,610 to $3,393 for a SwimClear C4030 in our model (PC&S price panel).
Are DE pool filters worth it?
They are if fine filtration matters more to you than upkeep. EPA lists DE at 5 microns against 20 to 40 for sand, but every backwash needs fresh powder (6.0 lb on a 48 sq ft Hayward Pro-Grid), grids last 2 to 3 years, and pool DE is 35 to 50% crystalline silica that calls for a dust mask and, in some cities, a separation tank (Celapool SDS).
How often should you add DE to a pool filter?
After every backwash or manual cleaning, because the coat leaves with the waste water. Use the label amount: Hayward calls for 1.25 lb per 10 sq ft on Pro-Grid filters and Pentair 3.6 to 6 lb on FNS Plus models. Backwash when the gauge reads 8 to 10 psi (Hayward) or about 10 psi (Pentair) above the reading after coating (Hayward Pro-Grid manual).
What are the downsides of using a sand filter?
Water and fineness. EPA rates sand at 20 to 40 microns, the coarsest of the three types, and a backwash on a Pentair TR60 sends 221 to 347 gallons to waste, 11,492 to 18,044 gallons a year at one backwash a week. Sand also needs replacing every 3 to 6 years: 300 lb, or 6 bags at $13.95, for a Hayward S244T (EPA WaterSense).
How big of a sand filter do I need for a 30000 gallon pool?
Size it to the pump and the turnover you want. Turning over 30,000 gallons in 8 hours takes 62.5 gpm. Hayward’s sell sheet shows a 24 inch S244T at 62 gpm turning over 29,760 gallons in 8 hours, just short, while the S310T2 at 98 gpm covers 47,040 (Hayward sell sheet). Pentair’s TR100 is rated 74 gpm.
Sources
- U.S. EPA. WaterSense: Making a Splash, Pool Water Efficiency (Sept 2022). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- CDC. Model Aquatic Health Code, 5th Edition (2024). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Intertek. Standards Update Notice, NSF/ANSI/CAN 50 (issued July 15, 2022; effective July 1, 2023). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Aquatics International. Needed Clarity: How NSF Evaluates and Tests Pool Filters (Sept 21, 2017). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Hayward. ProSeries High Rate Sand Filters Owner's Manual (IS210TS Rev A). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Hayward. ProSeries Top-Mount Sand Filters sell sheet (LITPROTM0SS24, 2024). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Hayward. SwimClear Cartridge Filter Owner's Manual (ISC2031EF Rev B). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Hayward. SwimClear Multi-Element Cartridge Filter 425 Sq.Ft. (C4030). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Hayward. Pro-Grid Vertical DE Filter Owner's Manual (ISDE2423EF Rev E). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Hayward. What are the Differences Between Filter Types? (May 22, 2023). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Pentair. Triton Side Mount Sand Filter Installation and User's Guide. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Pentair. Clean and Clear Plus Cartridge Filter Installation and User's Guide (2025). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Pentair. FNS Plus Vertical Grid D.E. Filter Installation and User's Guide (2025). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Intex (hosted by Home Depot). Krystal Clear Sand Filter Pump owner's manual (SF80110-2, SF70110-2, SF60110-2). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- California Energy Code Ace. 2025 Title 24, Part 6 Pool and Spa Heating fact sheet. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- New York State (Cornell LII). 10 NYCRR 6-1.11, Treatment. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- OSHA. 29 CFR 1910.1053, Respirable crystalline silica. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- EP Minerals (hosted by School Specialty). Celapool Safety Data Sheet (Jan 31, 2014). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- City of Surprise, Arizona. Draining your pool or spa the right way. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- County of San Diego. Pool, Spa, and Fountain Pollution Prevention Practices (June 5, 2026). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- City of Phoenix. Draining and Backwashing Your Pool. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- City of Thousand Oaks. Water Use (hand-held hose flow). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Simple Green. How to Clean a Cartridge Pool Filter. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Dave's Pool Store. SAND (Pool Filter Media), 50 lb bag. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Dave's Pool Store. Pool Grade D.E. Powder, 25 and 50 lb. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Dave's Pool Store. Vitroclean Glass Filter Media, 50 lb. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Waterline Technologies. #20 Grade Filtration Silica Sand, 50 lb. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- PoolBlu. Glass Filtration Media FG50. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- All Pool Filters 4 Less. Hayward CX880XRE cartridge. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- All Pool Filters 4 Less. Unicel FS-2004 DE grid set. Accessed 2026-10-27.
- PC&S. Pool Equipment Prices 2026 (PC&S research). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- PC&S. Pool Evaporation Rate refill table (PC&S research). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- All Filters. Pool Filter Types Compared (claims checked). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Beltway Pools. Pool filter types explained (claims checked). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Chloramine Consulting. Comparing Swimming Pool Filters (claims checked). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- Pinch A Penny. Swimming pool filter buyer's guide (claims checked). Accessed 2026-10-27.
- The Pool Factory. Sand Filters vs Cartridge Filters (claims checked). Accessed 2026-10-27.
Related pages
Get Quotes From Licensed Local Pool Pros
Tell us what you need and your ZIP code. We match you with pool companies that cover your area.