What some guides say,Who says it,What the primary source or arithmetic shows "Divide surface area by 3 and multiply by 1,000 for the minimum Btu",Leslie's; Inyo Pools,"That equals DOE's area x rise x 12 only at a 27.8 F rise. For a 10 F rise DOE gives 120 Btu/h per sq ft, not 333 (DOE Energy Saver)." Sizing by gallons is a common misconception,Leslie's,"Pentair's catalog sizes heaters by gallons for spot heating, and California's JA16.3 sizes heat pumps by gallons (Pentair p. 530; CEC JA16.3)." A cover cuts the Btu you need by about 30%,MBTEK calculator page,"DOE puts cover savings at 50% to 70% of heating cost, and DOE's sizing formula has no cover term (DOE Energy Saver)." "A 15 x 30 ft pool (about 17,000 gallons) heated 15 F over 24 hours needs roughly 72,000 Btu/h",MBTEK calculator page,"MBTEK's own formula (gallons x 8.34 x rise / hours, plus 25%) gives 110,766 Btu/h for those inputs (PC&S arithmetic)." Gas heaters add 1 F to 2 F per hour; heat pumps 0.5 F to 1 F,ePoolSupply,"Consistent with Pentair's formula for 20,000 gallons before losses: 2.01 F per hour at 400,000 input, 1.26 at 250,000, 0.84 for a 140,000 Btu/h heat pump at 80 F air, 0.51 at 50 F air." Heat pump size is the headline Btu rating,Spec sheets list the 80 F air rating first,The same AHRI 1160 tables show 61% to 68% of that output at 50 F air for the 7 models compared here (Hayward; Pentair).